Mr. Meherally is among the few Muslim apologists who put forth some original thoughts [although the quality of his papers have been inconsistent in recent months] as opposed to merely repeating the claims of other Muslim apologists whose trade mark it has often been to thoughtlessly copy arguments against the Bible used by atheists, Unitarians, and Jehovah's Witnesses, or other Muslim writers. We still think Mr. Meherally's articles represents biased research and contains major flaws, but his arguments are definitely some of the most cleverly constructed ones, especially when compared to the superficial arguments of other Muslim apologists such as Misha'al Al-Kadhi.

It is therefore no surprise that articles written by Akbarally Meherally are quite popular and are found on many Islamic sites. Sadly, some of his material is calculated deception, see, for example, the article Issues of Integrity.

This page will collect Christian responses to Mr. Meherally's claims, which he updates on a regular basis. To help our readers to more easily find our response articles, we follow the structure and sequence of presenting his pages on his own web site. At the end, we list responses to articles by Meherally, that are still available on various other Muslim sites, even though they are no longer in use by the author on his own web site.

[ It is interesting to note, that there are also Muslim rebuttals to A. Meherally's theories! ]

Muslim Rebuttals to Meherally:

• Under the subtitle Be Warned! Shahid bin Waheed presents several articles in response to Meherally's theories, concluding that Meherally is a heretic / apostate (Arabic: Murtad) and a liar even from a Muslim perspective.
• Many recognize that Meherally is not exactly orthodox. For example, on his Noorullah Website Hesham Azmy makes this comment: A web site by brother Meherally Akbarally. Sadly, it attacks some basic Islamic principles and propagates many belief anomalies. So, be aware!

Earlier material by Meherally, not or no longer in use on his own web site

Originally our rebuttal site started with Mr. Meherally's main entry on his web site, "The Bible FAQ". However, after the refutation of his article was presented by a Christian, Meherally has eventually removed it from of his site in the original format. It is however still available at various other web sites and the rebuttal is worth keeping also because similar arguments are made by many Muslims.

Even though Mr. Meherally has given up on the FAQ series itself, he has not repented of his errors but only reshuffled most of the material, given it a new title and a new sequence in which the old questions are presented. It is now called "Jesus, God or Not?", found above.

Rebuttals to Muslim polemics
Answering Islam Home Page